ONLINE + IN STORE

One Surprise Shop.

Everything you've seen on this page was built around one idea:

Make it easier to shop at your local card shop—whether you're standing inside it or hundreds of miles away.

The Surprise Shop isn't an online marketplace, a warehouse, or a website operated somewhere behind the scenes.

We're a real brick-and-mortar card and collectibles shop in Sullivan, Missouri.

The cards you see online are the same physical inventory our team works with inside the store every day.

Shop From Anywhere

You don't have to live in Sullivan to shop with us.

Our website brings The Surprise Shop to customers anywhere we can ship.

Browse our singles. See scans of the actual cards. Build a Watchlist. Start a trade. Ask Genevieve a question. Place an order.

You get the convenience of shopping online while still buying from a real independent card shop.

Or Come See Us

If you're nearby, we'd love to see you in person.

Walk through the doors and you're visiting the same shop that's behind the website.

Browse the store, check out the latest cards and collectibles, bring us something you're interested in trading, or just stop in and see what's new.

We're located at:

The Surprise Shop
104 W Main St
Sullivan, MO 63080

Physical and Digital, Working Together

We don't see our website and our physical store as two different businesses.

They're two ways to experience the same Surprise Shop.

A card can enter our inventory through the physical store, be inspected and scanned by our team, appear online for someone across the country, and then be pulled from its location inside the shop when that customer places an order.

Technology helps connect everything.

But there's still a real card, in a real shop, with real people behind it.

Built in a Small Town. Available Far Beyond It.

The Surprise Shop calls Sullivan, Missouri home, and we're proud of that.

We're building technology that allows a local independent shop to offer an online experience that can reach far beyond our front door—without losing what makes a local card shop special in the first place.

Whether you're five minutes away or five hundred miles away, when you shop with us, you're shopping with The Surprise Shop.

One Shop. Two Ways to Visit.

Come through our front door in Sullivan.

Or visit us from wherever you happen to be.

Either way:

WELCOME TO THE SURPRISE SHOP.

SHOP ONLINE | VISIT THE STORE