Skip to content
GIVE US A FOLLOW ON FACEBOOK
Help My Account
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • BUSINESS HOURS
  • FAQ
  • TCG SUBSCRIPTION
  • TRADE IN
  • EVENT CALENDAR
  • MAGIC: THE GATHERING
    • MAGIC: THE GATHERING
    • THE HOBBIT
    • MARVEL SUPER HEROES
    • SECRETS OF STRIXHAVEN
    • LORWYN ECLIPSED
    • TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES
    • ALL MAGIC SETS
    • ALL SINGLES
  • POKEMON
    • POKEMON
    • PERFECT ORDER
    • ASCENDED HEROES
    • PHANTASMAL FLAMES
    • ALL POKEMON SETS
    • ALL SINGLES
  • YU-GI-OH! SETS
  • SEALED PRODUCT
    • SEALED PRODUCT
    • SEALED MAGIC THE GATHERING
    • SEALED POKEMON
    • SEALED YU-GI-OH
    • SEALED LORCANA
    • STARWARS UNLIMITED
    • SEALED MISCELLANEOUS
  • CARD ACCESSORIES
  • SWEET SURPRISES
  • TOYS
  • CARD WATCHLIST
  • HOW THE SURPRISE SHOP WORKS
    • HOW THE SURPRISE SHOP WORKS
    • SMART CARD PRICING - TCGPLAYER MARKET PRICE
    • REAL SCANS. REAL CARDS. NO SURPRISES.
    • STOP SEARCHING. WE'LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN IT'S HERE
    • MEET GENEVIEVE
    • TRADE WITH US
    • SHIPPING SINGLES
    • ONLINE + IN STORE
  • FIGURES
  • VIDEO GAMES
    • VIDEO GAMES
    • PlayStation 5
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox 360
    • Switch 2
  • My Account
The Surprise Shop

Quality since 1993

Popular searches

  • Deck Box
  • Card Sleeves
  • Magic The Gathering

Discord

Join Our Community

Cart
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • BUSINESS HOURS
  • FAQ
  • TCG SUBSCRIPTION
  • TRADE IN
  • EVENT CALENDAR
  • MAGIC: THE GATHERING
    • THE HOBBIT
    • MARVEL SUPER HEROES
    • SECRETS OF STRIXHAVEN
    • LORWYN ECLIPSED
    • TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES
    • ALL MAGIC SETS
    • ALL SINGLES
  • POKEMON
    • PERFECT ORDER
    • ASCENDED HEROES
    • PHANTASMAL FLAMES
    • ALL POKEMON SETS
    • ALL SINGLES
  • YU-GI-OH! SETS
  • SEALED PRODUCT
    • SEALED MAGIC THE GATHERING
    • SEALED POKEMON
    • SEALED YU-GI-OH
    • SEALED LORCANA
    • STARWARS UNLIMITED
    • SEALED MISCELLANEOUS
  • CARD ACCESSORIES
  • SWEET SURPRISES
  • TOYS
  • CARD WATCHLIST
  • HOW THE SURPRISE SHOP WORKS
    • SMART CARD PRICING - TCGPLAYER MARKET PRICE
    • REAL SCANS. REAL CARDS. NO SURPRISES.
    • STOP SEARCHING. WE'LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN IT'S HERE
    • MEET GENEVIEVE
    • TRADE WITH US
    • SHIPPING SINGLES
    • ONLINE + IN STORE
  • FIGURES
  • VIDEO GAMES
    • PlayStation 5
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox 360
    • Switch 2
  1. Home /
  2. Search

Search

Popular searches

  • Deck Box
  • Card Sleeves
  • Magic The Gathering

Found 1002 results for “Magic The Gathering”

  • Portal to Phyrexia (Extended Art) – 365 BRO: The Brothers' War M Foil NM

    Portal to Phyrexia (Extended Art) – 365 BRO: The Brothers' War M Foil NM

    Regular price $99.39
    Sale price $99.39 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Parallel Lives – 58 WOT: Wilds of Eldraine: Enchanting Tales M LP

    Parallel Lives – 58 WOT: Wilds of Eldraine: Enchanting Tales M LP

    Regular price $38.75
    Sale price $38.75 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Marvel Super Heroes - Collector Booster Pack

    Marvel Super Heroes - Collector Booster Pack

    Regular price $49.95
    Sale price $49.95 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • FINAL FANTASY Commander Deck - FINAL FANTASY X Counter Blitz

    FINAL FANTASY Commander Deck - FINAL FANTASY X Counter Blitz

    Regular price $45.95
    Sale price $45.95 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Sorin of House Markov (Borderless) (Textured Foil) – 470 MH3: Modern Horizons 3 M Foil NM

    Sorin of House Markov (Borderless) (Textured Foil) – 470 MH3: Modern Horizons 3 M Foil NM

    Regular price $44.61
    Sale price $44.61 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Season of Gathering (Borderless) – 286 BLB: Bloomburrow M NM

    Season of Gathering (Borderless) – 286 BLB: Bloomburrow M NM

    Regular price $9.13
    Sale price $9.13 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Aetherdrift Commander Deck - Living Energy

    Aetherdrift Commander Deck - Living Energy

    Regular price $32.95
    Sale price $32.95 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Vaultborn Tyrant – 20 PPECL: Promo Pack: Lorwyn Eclipsed M NM

    Vaultborn Tyrant – 20 PPECL: Promo Pack: Lorwyn Eclipsed M NM

    Regular price $38.09
    Sale price $38.09 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Weathered Wayfarer – 59 ONS: Onslaught R LP

    Weathered Wayfarer – 59 ONS: Onslaught R LP

    Regular price $17.04
    Sale price $17.04 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Steal the Show – 130 SOS: Secrets of Strixhaven R NM

    Steal the Show – 130 SOS: Secrets of Strixhaven R NM

    Regular price $0.30
    Sale price $0.30 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Unmask – 168 MMQ: Mercadian Masques R NM

    Unmask – 168 MMQ: Mercadian Masques R NM

    Regular price $23.86
    Sale price $23.86 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Marvel Super Heroes - Jumpstart Booster Pack

    Marvel Super Heroes - Jumpstart Booster Pack

    Regular price $8.95
    Sale price $8.95 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Ultimate Guard Playmat - MTG - Reality Fracture - White Mythic

    Ultimate Guard Playmat - MTG - Reality Fracture - White Mythic

    Regular price $29.95
    Sale price $29.95 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • The Grey Havens – 255 LTR: Universes Beyond: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth U NM

    The Grey Havens – 255 LTR: Universes Beyond: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth U NM

    Regular price $0.28
    Sale price $0.28 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Dig Site Inventory – 10 SOS: Secrets of Strixhaven C

    Dig Site Inventory – 10 SOS: Secrets of Strixhaven C

    Regular price $0.11
    Sale price $0.11 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
  • Elven Chorus – 160 LTR: Universes Beyond: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth R NM

    Elven Chorus – 160 LTR: Universes Beyond: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth R NM

    Regular price $3.44
    Sale price $3.44 Regular price
    Unit price /  per 
Show more
Scroll to the top of the page

The Surprise Shop

104 W Main St Sullivan Mo, 63080

Call Us At (573) 468-6932

Feel Free to leave us a review here.

Check Us Out On Ebay


Our physical store houses over 1.8 million individual items. Beyond trading cards, we carry an even wider selection on our eBay page - sports memorabilia, video games, home decor, toys, and many more collectibles! With over 25,000 items sold and Top Rated Seller status, you can shop with confidence. Check it out here!

Menu

  • FAQs
  • CONTACT US
  • REFUND POLICY
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF SERVICE

Business Hours


Monday: 9 AM–5 PM

Tuesday: 9 AM–5 PM

Wednesday: 9 AM–5 PM

Thursday: 9 AM–5 PM

Friday: 9 AM–5 PM

Saturday: 9 AM–5 PM

Sunday: Closed

Contact Us

Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Visa
© 2026, The Surprise Shop . Powered by Shopify
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.